Nickel mine exploitation threats to Sulawesi’s natural environment
14 November, 2024
Thursday 23 april 2020
Header photo by: BEES
“For most civil society organisations (CSOs) in Benin, it’s not easy to influence government bodies without having what we call ‘our (wo)man inside’,” says Maximin Djondo, Director of the Benin Environment and Education Society (BEES). “People in government want to separate civil-society from law-making. But recently, things have started to change for us.”
One of Maximin’s contacts, Mr. Raphael Edou, plays a vital role. Raphael has worked as a consultant for CSOs, including Maximin’s organisation BEES, for many years. For people working for nature conservation, he’s managed to obtain a key position.
Maximin: ‘We used to cooperate with Raphael in a coalition of CSOs to lobby for clean, sustainable wetlands. We’d consult him for expert views on solid waste management, so that we’d know what to discuss with the government during our lobby.’ And guess what? In 2013, Raphael was appointed Minister of Environment in Benin. This is when he became Maximin’s ‘man inside’.
Maximin: ‘Now we could directly call all Raphael’s staff members, like the person responsible for international agreements or the person working on climate change. We’d talk about what we need from them, and what they want from us as CSOs. Communicating directly helps a great deal in advancing our work. Now formal letters actually find their way to the person responsible, instead of being lost in a huge pile on the assistant’s desk.’
Being in touch with the right people inside the government is one thing, but institutionalizing your connection is equally important.
Maximin: ‘Raphael left his position as Minister of Environment about two years later. Often, a collaboration then stops. But what we did is institutionalize it in a memorandum of understanding, which helps us to continue our work even if our man or woman inside leaves office. However, a little more action is desirable. Because a new minister can simply choose to ignore such a memorandum. That’s why you still need continuous, strong lobby and advocacy for your efforts to be successful.’
‘Over the last 20 years, the most important thing I’ve discovered is that only together we stand strong.’
The memorandum of understanding states that the CSOs and the government meet every six months to discuss the status of the environment. Here, the government informs the CSOs about their plans impacting the environment and the CSOs present the projects they’re implementing in the country.
So what were the outcomes of Maximin’s efforts? Maximin: ‘We are truly happy about working together with the government. We meet every six months and I get invited to discuss new policies, for example on forestry. But even though we talk a lot, we as CSOs would like to implement more projects in the country.’
Luckily, whenever they do set up a project with local governments or communities, for example capacity building, Maximin can prove it’s supported by the central government. ‘I simply invite a Minister or Chief of Cabinet to have a talk at the beginning of the session, showing that the Ministry of Environment, Agriculture or Water, has our back. This legitimizes our actions.’
‘Over the last 20 years, the most important thing I’ve discovered is that it is only together we stand strong,’ says Maximin. Maybe you’re a small CSO, or maybe you’ve only just started out. But your network is valuable anytime and through different ways. It’s important to acknowledge that it’s all intertwined. By working together with your contacts at the government, you have an impact on legislation.
The lessons learned from this case summed up:
Thanks to their network, Maximin and his colleagues drafted a law on banning single use plastics. And it passed! Watch the video to find out how they managed to do this.
This article is part of the series Lessons on business engagement for nature conservation.
We are also interested in hearing your experiences of how companies, civil society organisations and governments can work towards joint solutions.
How did the collaboration between governments and civil society organisations work for you? Have you found your (wo)man inside yet? Share your experiences!